All Time Manager Rankings

A convoluded formula creates a tie at the top.

1) 651 Pts - Lou Poulas (1 Chg)

1) 651 Pts - Justin Petronzi (0 Chg)

3) 626 Pts - Mike Smitko (0 Chg)

4) 609 Pts - Steve Chippendale (0 Chg)

5) 587 Pts - Jason Bernarndon (0 Chg)

6) 577 Pts - Sean Seeley (0 Chg)

7) 562 Pts - Brad Peterson (0 Chg)

8) 553 Pts - David Kuenn (8 Chg)

9) 543 Pts - Johnny Kondovski (-1 Chg)

10) 540 Pts - Elliot Goldbetter (-1 Chg)

11) 531 Pts - Joe Terry (-1 Chg)

12) 529 Pts - TJ Olszewski (-1 Chg)

13) 523 Pts - Matt Brody (2 Chg)

14) 513 Pts - Joe Valenzano (7 Chg)

15) 512 Pts - Jeff Burns (-3 Chg)

16) 512 Pts - Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein (-3 Chg)

17) 509 Pts - Shotgun Spratling (-3 Chg)

18) 508 Pts - Brian Barnes (0 Chg)

19) 494 Pts - Jay Seeley (-2 Chg)

20) 488 Pts - Ivar Anderson (-1 Chg)

21) 483 Pts - Joe Poulas (-1 Chg)

22) 474 Pts - Leanne Sarubbi (2 Chg)

23) 447 Pts - Jay Hattem (-1 Chg)

24) 434 Pts - Kevin Crowley (-1 Chg)

25) 415 Pts - Gary Gambino (1 Chg)

26) 384 Pts - Allen Cherulnik  (-1 Chg)

27) 306 Pts - Justin Burnson (0 Chg)

28) 306 Pts - Scott Carter (0 Chg)

29) 297 Pts - Mike Green (0 Chg)

30) 292 Pts - Justin Bossert (0 Chg)

31) 280 Pts - Mike Murphy (1 Chg)

32) 275 Pts - Bruce Nalepka (-1 Chg)

33) 260 Pts - Michael Rippe (0 Chg)

34) 256 Pts - Larry Caggiano (0 Chg)

35) 238 Pts - Steve Gray / Tommy Bligh (0 Chg)

36) 235 Pts - Jim Nugent (0 Chg)

37) 235 Pts - Richard Madachik (0 Chg)

38) 235 Pts - Stephen Lee (NA Chg)

39) 235 Pts - Thomas Richards (NA Chg)

40) 234 Pts - Matt Hinzpeter (-2 Chg)

41) 231 Pts - Mike Wishnick (-2 Chg)

42) 231 Pts - Scott Salley (-2 Chg)

43) 225 Pts - Dennis Slinger (-1 Chg)

44) 225 Pts - Ted Knorr (-1 Chg)

45) 225 Pts - Tony Pelligrino (NA Chg)

46) 222 Pts - John J (NA Chg)

47) 221 Pts - Greg Murphy (5 Chg)

48) 221 Pts - Ben Matsil (-4 Chg)

49) 216 Pts - Bob Lessard (-4 Chg)

50) 216 Pts - PJ Dodds (-4 Chg)

51) 213 Pts - Paul Nebenfuer (-4 Chg)

52) 210 Pts - Devon Eckhart (-4 Chg)

53) 210 Pts - Andy Matsil (-4 Chg)

54) 210 Pts - Greg Stillwagon (-4 Chg)

55) 208 Pts - Al Hastick (-14 Chg)

56) 207 Pts - Jason Schwartz (-5 Chg)

57) 198 Pts - John Wolford (-4 Chg)

58) 194 Pts - Chris Kelly (-4 Chg)

59) 192 Pts - Adam Bloomquist (-4 Chg)

60) 188 Pts - Rod Aukamp (-4 Chg)

61) 188 Pts - Adam Luther (-4 Chg)

62) 185 Pts - Lee Wykes (-4 Chg)

63) 185 Pts - Bill Nyman (-4 Chg)

64) 173 Pts - Paul Taschereau Jr (-4 Chg)

65) 167 Pts - Neil Book (-4 Chg)

66) 164 Pts - Mario Iafrate & Russ Palmer (-4 Chg)

All Time Manager Power Rankings Update - CORRECTION

1) 650 Pts - Justin Petronzi (+1 Chg)
2) 649 Pts - Lou Poulas (-1 Chg)
3) 628 Pts - Mike Smitko (0 Chg)
4) 609 Pts - Steve Chippendale (0 Chg)
5) 591 Pts - Jason Bernarndon (1 Chg)
6) 576 Pts - Sean Seeley (-1 Chg)
7) 563 Pts - Brad Peterson (0 Chg)
8) 543 Pts - Johnny Kondovski (0 Chg)
9) 540 Pts - Elliot Goldbetter (0 Chg)
10) 539 Pts - Joe Terry (0 Chg)
11) 532 Pts - TJ Olszewski (0 Chg)
12) 512 Pts - Jeff Burns (1 Chg)
13) 512 Pts - Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein (1 Chg)
14) 509 Pts - Shotgun Spratling (3 Chg)
15) 505 Pts - Matt Brody (0 Chg)
16) 495 Pts - David Kuenn (2 Chg)
17) 494 Pts - Jay Seeley (-1 Chg)
18) 494 Pts - Brian Barnes (2 Chg)
19) 489 Pts - Ivar Anderson (0 Chg)
20) 483 Pts - Joe Poulas (1 Chg)
21) 459 Pts - Joe Valenzano (5 Chg)
22) 447 Pts - Jay Hattem (3 Chg)
23) 434 Pts - Kevin Crowley (1 Chg)
24) 428 Pts - Leane Sarubbi (-2 Chg)
25) 375 Pts - Allen Cherulnik  (6 Chg)
26) 370 Pts - Gary Gambino (3 Chg)
27) 306 Pts - Justin Burnson (-15 Chg)
28) 306 Pts - Scott Carter (7 Chg)
29) 297 Pts - Mike Green (7 Chg)
30) 297 Pts - Justin Bossert (NA Chg)
31) 275 Pts - Bruce Nalepka (7 Chg)
32) 267 Pts - Mike Murphy (5 Chg)
33) 260 Pts - Michael Rippe (-10 Chg)
34) 256 Pts - Larry Caggiano (5 Chg)
35) 238 Pts - Steve Gray / Tommy Bligh (-8 Chg)
36) 235 Pts - Jim Nugent (4 Chg)
37) 235 Pts - Richard Madachik (4 Chg)
38) 234 Pts - Matt Hinzpeter (-10 Chg)
39) 231 Pts - Mike Wishnick (3 Chg)
40) 231 Pts - Scott Salley (3 Chg)
41) 231 Pts - Al Hastick (NA Chg)
42) 225 Pts - Dennis Slinger (2 Chg)
43) 225 Pts - Ted Knorr (2 Chg)
44) 221 Pts - Ben Matsil (-14 Chg)
45) 216 Pts - Bob Lessard (1 Chg)
46) 216 Pts - PJ Dodds (NA Chg)
47) 213 Pts - Paul Nebenfuer (0 Chg)
48) 210 Pts - Devon Eckhart (-16 Chg)
49) 210 Pts - Andy Matsil (-16 Chg)
50) 210 Pts - Greg Stillwagon (-2 Chg)
51) 207 Pts - Jason Schwartz (-2 Chg)
52) 204 Pts - Greg Murphy (0 Chg)
53) 198 Pts - John Wolford (-3 Chg)
54) 194 Pts - Chris Kelly (-3 Chg)
55) 192 Pts - Adam Bloomquist (-21 Chg)
56) 188 Pts - Rod Aukamp (-3 Chg)
57) 188 Pts - Adam Luther (-3 Chg)
58) 185 Pts - Lee Wykes (-3 Chg)
59) 185 Pts - Bill Nyman (-3 Chg)
60) 173 Pts - Paul Taschereau Jr (-3 Chg)
61) 167 Pts - Neil Book (-3 Chg)
62) 164 Pts - Mario Iafrate & Russ Palmer (-3 Chg)

Justin is the new leader!!!  I had a formula error.

http://www.alltimebaseballsim.net/All%20Time%20Managers%20Through%20ATB%20XVI.xlsx

All Time Manager Rankings

Here is the worksheet

http://www.alltimebaseballsim.net/All Time Managers Through ATB XV.xlsx

1) 651 Pts - Lou Poulas (0 Chg)
2) 638 Pts - Justin Petronzi (0 Chg)
3) 626 Pts - Mike Smitko (0 Chg)
4) 602 Pts - Steve Chippendale (0 Chg)
5) 579 Pts - Sean Seeley (0 Chg)
6) 575 Pts - Jason Bernarndon (1 Chg)
7) 565 Pts - Brad Peterson (-1 Chg)
8) 543 Pts - Johnny Kondovski (1 Chg)
9) 540 Pts - Elliot Goldbetter (4 Chg)
10) 538 Pts - Joe Terry (1 Chg)
11) 531 Pts - TJ Olszewski (-1 Chg)
12) 520 Pts - Justin Burnson (-4 Chg)
13) 518 Pts - Jeff Burns (-1 Chg)
14) 512 Pts - Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein (0 Chg)
15) 500 Pts - Matt Brody (3 Chg)
16) 494 Pts - Jay Seeley (-1 Chg)
17) 492 Pts - Shotgun Spratling (-1 Chg)
18) 490 Pts - David Kuenn (18 Chg)
19) 489 Pts - Ivar Anderson (2 Chg)
20) 483 Pts - Brian Barnes (2 Chg)
21) 483 Pts - Joe Poulas (-4 Chg)
22) 478 Pts - Leane Sarubbi (-2 Chg)
23) 441 Pts - Michael Rippe (-4 Chg)
24) 434 Pts - Kevin Crowley (1 Chg)
25) 432 Pts - Jay Hattem (2 Chg)
26) 408 Pts - Joe Valenzano (NA Chg)
27) 404 Pts - Steve Gray / Tommy Bligh (-4 Chg)
28) 398 Pts - Matt Hinzpeter (-4 Chg)
29) 382 Pts - Gary Gambino (12 Chg)
30) 376 Pts - Ben Matsil (-4 Chg)
31) 363 Pts - Allen Cherulnik  (-1 Chg)
32) 357 Pts - Devon Eckhart (-4 Chg)
33) 357 Pts - Andy Matsil (-4 Chg)
34) 326 Pts - Adam Bloomquist (-3 Chg)
35) 306 Pts - Scott Carter (-3 Chg)
36) 297 Pts - Mike Green (-3 Chg)
37) 281 Pts - Mike Murphy (NA Chg)
38) 275 Pts - Bruce Nalepka (-4 Chg)
39) 256 Pts - Larry Caggiano (-4 Chg)
40) 235 Pts - Jim Nugent (-3 Chg)
41) 235 Pts - Richard Madachik (-3 Chg)
42) 231 Pts - Mike Wishnick (-3 Chg)
43) 231 Pts - Scott Salley (-3 Chg)
44) 225 Pts - Dennis Slinger (-2 Chg)
45) 225 Pts - Ted Knorr (NA Chg)
46) 216 Pts - Bob Lessard (-3 Chg)
47) 213 Pts - Paul Nebenfuer (-3 Chg)
48) 210 Pts - Greg Stillwagon (-3 Chg)
49) 207 Pts - Jason Schwartz (-2 Chg)
50) 198 Pts - John Wolford (-2 Chg)
51) 194 Pts - Chris Kelly (-2 Chg)
52) 194 Pts - Greg Murphy (NA Chg)
53) 188 Pts - Ron Aukamp (-3 Chg)
54) 188 Pts - Adam Luther (-3 Chg)
55) 185 Pts - Lee Wykes (-3 Chg)
56) 185 Pts - Bill Nyman (NA Chg)
57) 173 Pts - Paul Taschereau Jr (-4 Chg)
58) 167 Pts - Neil Book (-4 Chg)
59) 164 Pts - Mario Iafrate & Russ Palmer (-4 Chg)

Updated Career Manager Standings

http://www.alltimebaseballsim.net/ATB_Mgr_Stand.htm



1) 648 Pts - Lou Poulas (0 Chg)
2) 631 Pts - Justin Petronzi (0 Chg)
3) 630 Pts - Mike Smitko (0 Chg)
4) 595 Pts - Steve Chippendale (0 Chg)
5) 574 Pts - Sean Seeley (0 Chg)
6) 566 Pts - Brad Peterson (1 Chg)
7) 563 Pts - Jason Bernarndon (-1 Chg)
8) 551 Pts - Justin Burnson (22 Chg)
9) 543 Pts - Johnny Kondovski (-1 Chg)
10) 530 Pts - TJ Olszewski (0 Chg)
11) 528 Pts - Joe Terry (-2 Chg)
12) 526 Pts - Jeff Burns (1 Chg)
13) 524 Pts - Elliot Goldbetter (-2 Chg)
14) 512 Pts - Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein (-2 Chg)
15) 494 Pts - Jay Seeley (1 Chg)
16) 493 Pts - Shotgun Spratling (2 Chg)
17) 483 Pts - Joe Poulas (-3 Chg)
18) 482 Pts - Matt Brody (-3 Chg)
19) 467 Pts - Michael Rippe (2 Chg)
20) 465 Pts - Leane Sarubbi (2 Chg)
21) 460 Pts - Ivar Anderson (-4 Chg)
22) 458 Pts - Brian Barnes (-2 Chg)
23) 428 Pts - Steve Gray / Tommy Bligh (0 Chg)
24) 422 Pts - Matt Hinzpeter (0 Chg)
25) 421 Pts - Kevin Crowley (-6 Chg)
26) 398 Pts - Ben Matsil (0 Chg)
27) 393 Pts - Jay Hattem (-2 Chg)
28) 378 Pts - Devon Eckhart (0 Chg)
29) 378 Pts - Andy Matsil (0 Chg)
30) 358 Pts - Allen Cherulnik  (-3 Chg)
31) 345 Pts - Adam Bloomquist (0 Chg)
32) 306 Pts - Scott Carter (0 Chg)
33) 297 Pts - Mike Green (NA Chg)
34) 275 Pts - Bruce Nalepka (-1 Chg)
35) 256 Pts - Larry Caggiano (-1 Chg)
36) 253 Pts - David Kuenn (NA Chg)
37) 235 Pts - Jim Nugent (-2 Chg)
38) 235 Pts - Richard Madachik (-2 Chg)
39) 231 Pts - Mike Wishnick (-2 Chg)
40) 231 Pts - Scott Salley (-2 Chg)
41) 228 Pts - Gary Gambino (NA Chg)
42) 225 Pts - Dennis Slinger (-3 Chg)
43) 216 Pts - Bob Lessard (-3 Chg)
44) 213 Pts - Paul Nebenfuer (NA Chg)
45) 210 Pts - Greg Stillwagon (-4 Chg)
46) 207 Pts - Joe Valenzano (NA Chg)
47) 207 Pts - Jason Schwartz (NA Chg)
48) 198 Pts - John Wolford (-6 Chg)
49) 194 Pts - Chris Kelly (-6 Chg)
50) 188 Pts - Rod Aukamp (-6 Chg)
51) 188 Pts - Adam Luther (-6 Chg)
52) 185 Pts - Lee Wykes (-6 Chg)
53) 173 Pts - Paul Taschereau Jr (-6 Chg)
54) 167 Pts - Neil Book (-6 Chg)
55) 164 Pts - Mario Iafrate & Russ Palmer (-6 Chg)

All Time Standings Update

Despite not making the playoffs, Lou P jumps to first place overall after last years leader Justin P, suffers through a dismal 68 win season. There were no other major changes in the standings.

Here are the full standings.

A note on methodology. The all time standings are based upon regular season winning percentage, # of post seasons made, # of world series titles, and # of seasons played.

The last is a critcal point to understand. We have owners who have played 4 seasons and others who have played for 14. The owner with relatively few seasons under his belt would never have a shot at the # 1 Ranking if we just used the total regular season wins. But, by the same token, it would be fair for a new owner with 1 great season under his belt to be ranked #1 overall.

For the past 5 years or so, I've instituted a reduction policy. The Power Point total is reduced by percentage points based upon # of seasons played:

No Reduction - 7+ seasons
5% Reduction - 4-6 seasons
10% Reduction - 3 seasons
20% Reduction - 2 seasons
50% Reduction - 1 seasons

Here are the current standings with a few owners removed not playing recently and have few seasons to their credit:

1) 638 Pts - Lou Poulas
2) 634 Pts - Justin Petronzi
3) 632 Pts - Mike Smitko
4) 607 Pts - Steve Chippendale
5) 573 Pts - Sean Seeley
6) 571 Pts - Jason Bernarndon
7) 566 Pts - Brad Peterson
8) 543 Pts - Johnny Kondovski
9) 532 Pts - Joe Terry
10) 529 Pts - TJ Olszewski
11) 524 Pts - Elliot Goldbetter
12) 512 Pts - Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein
13) 502 Pts - Jeff Burns
14) 483 Pts - Joe Poulas
15) 482 Pts - Matt Brody
16) 473 Pts - Jay Seeley
17) 457 Pts - Ivar Anderson
18) 442 Pts - Shotgun Spratling
19) 421 Pts - Kevin Crowley
20) 417 Pts - Brian Barnes
27) 339 Pts - Allen Cherulnik
30) 315 Pts - Justin Burnson
46) 185 Pts - Lee Wykes

World Series Page

All Time Manager Ranking Update

With his second career world series win and the most career victories of all time, Justin P moves into first place in the All Time Manager rankings. His 645 Power Points narrowly surpass Lou P, who moves into second with 643 points.

Here is the new top 10 and current rankings for all owners with a squad in ATB XII.

TOP 10
1) 645 Pts - Justin Petronzi
2) 643 Pts - Lou Poulas
3) 631 Pts - Mike Smitko
4) 582 Pts - Steve Chippendale
5) 572 Pts - Sean Seeley
6) 568 Pts - Brad Peterson
7) 558 Pts - Jason Bernarndon
8) 543 Pts - Johnny Kondovski
9) 526 Pts - TJ Olszewski
10) 524 Pts - Elliot Goldbetter

Rank for ATB XII Owners
1) 645 Pts - Justin Petronzi
2) 643 Pts - Lou Poulas
3) 631 Pts - Mike Smitko
4) 582 Pts - Steve Chippendale
6) 568 Pts - Brad Peterson
7) 558 Pts - Jason Bernarndon
9) 526 Pts - TJ Olszewski
11) 501 Pts - Jeff Burns
12) 491 Pts - Joe Terry
13) 485 Pts - Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein
16) 428 Pts - Matt Brody
17) 427 Pts - Ivar Anderson
18) 421 Pts - Kevin Crowley
20) 413 Pts - Leane Sarubbi
21) 385 Pts - Brian Barnes
24) 367 Pts - Shotgun Spratling
25) 360 Pts - Jay Hattem
31) 297 Pts - Allen ? 35)
235 Pts - Richard Madachik
41) 198 Pts - John Wolford

Keep in mind longevity is a key metric here and new owners need to be active for a considerable # of seasons to not suffer a point penalty.

Here are the Top 20 Owners for all time winning percentage (no minimum)
1) 0.619, Steve Chippendale
2) 0.611, Scott Carter
3) 0.604, Justin Petronzi
4) 0.601, Jason Bernarndon
5) 0.596, Lou Poulas
6) 0.585, Mike Smitko
7) 0.549, Bruce Nalepka
8) 0.537, Sean Seeley
8) 0.537, Joe Terry
10) 0.528, Brad Peterson
11) 0.525, Elliot Goldbetter
12) 0.522, Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein
13) 0.515, Michael Rippe
14) 0.512, Larry Caggiano
15) 0.509, Leane Sarubbi
16) 0.500, Jeff Burns
17) 0.498, Joe Poulas
18) 0.496, Johnny Kondovski
19) 0.495, Jay Seeley
20) 0.482, TJ Olszewski

Finally, all the detail can be found here.

All Time ATB Managerial Records

I struggle with all time owner rankings because I can't tell where the divide should be. I feel strongly that owners who have played for years should be ranked higher than some of those with just a few seasons, but how best to do that?

Best case to illustrate. TJO has played 11 seasons with an 861-917 record (.484 Wpct). Should he be ranked better that Steve C who has a .620 win percentage in two seasons? You got me.

I made the cut-off for major penalty at 2 or less seasons. Each teams rank takes into consideration:

• Career Winning Percentage
• Season High Winning Percentage
• Playoff Appearances
• World Series Titles
• Minor penalty for under 4 or 6 seasons played (out of 11)
  
• Moderate penalty for 3 seasons played
• Major penalty for 2 seasons played
• Critical Penalty for 1 season played (no one time can be ranked higher than anyone with more than 1 season under their belt)
  

Hope it is fair. Top 10 below, complete list with records here.

1) 642 Pts - Lou Poulas
2) 637 Pts - Justin Petronzi
3) 627 Pts - Mike Smitko
4) 572 Pts - Sean Seeley
5) 567 Pts - Brad Peterson
6) 543 Pts - Johnny Kondovski
7) 528 Pts - TJ Olszewski
8) 524 Pts - Elliot Goldbetter
9) 518 Pts - Steve Chippendale
10) 513 Pts - Jason Bernarndon
11) 502 Pts - Jeff Burns
12) 483 Pts - Joe Poulas
13) 473 Pts - Jay Seeley
14) 460 Pts - Mike Thanasides & Zach Bernstein
15) 422 Pts - Joe Terry
16) 421 Pts - Kevin Crowley
17) 417 Pts - Ivar Anderson
18) 415 Pts - Michael Rippe
19) 380 Pts - Steve Gray / Tommy Bligh
20) 380 Pts - Matt Brody